Silvacom News

Market-Based Instruments for Environmental Management

Written by Toni Anderson, BBA, MScF, EP | June 27, 2016

Government regulation has long been the traditional mechanism employed to avoid environmental degradation. These Command and Control (CAC) policies tell companies what the environmental standards are and how to meet them. 

Consider popular environmental policies: emission standards, equipment specifications, disclosure requirements, etc.

In recent years, CAC policies have been criticized for discouraging innovation. However, these policies didn’t gain popularity without reason. When employed correctly, imposing fixed standards can quickly change industry behaviour. When time is of the essence, this is essential. CACs are also efficient when pollution comes from one identifiable source. Think of it like this: if only a handful of people owned vehicles, it would be easy to impose fixed standards, allocating a maximum amount of travel time each day to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. As more vehicles are added to the road, it becomes harder to monitor each one. Eventually, the number of people driving outweighs the number of enforcement officers, and the policy becomes nearly impossible to implement successfully.

Filling the Policy Gap

When CACs become inefficient, Market-based Instruments (MBIs) can fill the policy gap. Simply put, MBIs are policy instruments that provide polluters with monetary incentives to reduce their emissions. There are different types of MBIs, grouped into two broad categories:

  • Transferable permits
  • Taxes and subsidies

Market-Based Instruments: Transferable Permits

Transferable permits are most common under a cap-and-trade system. This is when the government sets an emissions threshold, and the industry must figure out how, as a group, to stay under it. Each company is allocated a number of permits, and some will develop new technologies to reduce emissions further, selling their remaining permits to other companies still emitting above the threshold. When MBIs establish a new market (i.e., where buyers and sellers trade environmental credits), each transaction can decrease environmental degradation while also adding value to the economy. Once thought of as two mutually exclusive goals, this system makes it possible to achieve both at the same time.

Market-Based Instruments: Taxes and Subsidies

Taxes and subsidies have been used to change industry behaviour for much longer than transferable permits. Rather than setting an emissions cap, companies can choose when emissions become too expensive because of the tax rate. This gives polluters a strong incentive to continually reduce their emissions by investing in new technologies or purchasing additional offsets.

The Future of Environmental Policy in Alberta

CACs and MBIs are both instrumental for strong environmental policy. Alberta already uses MBIs for large emitters. Under the Technology Innovation and Emissions Reduction (TIER) Regulation, facilities that beat their emissions benchmark earn credits they can sell, while others can buy credits or offsets to comply. Alberta’s Biodiversity Management Framework for the Lower Athabasca region, still in development, could also set the stage for transferable permits by establishing ecological thresholds for indicators such as caribou habitat, native land cover, and old-growth forest.

How Can We Help?

Silvacom has extensive experience in prioritizing areas for restoration, offset optimization planning, and general ecosystem services analyses. For more information on how we can help your company adapt, please contact us.